Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner in 77 VS. Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black

Hey everyone,

Yesterday I picked up the Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black on a whim while out with a friend. I tried it a bit yesterday, but here's a full review on it compared to my Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner in 77

Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner:

• There is 3g of product (0.106 oz.)
• Was around $7 at Walmart
• Claims to be safe for sensitive eyes, highly pigmented, smudge and waterproof up to 24 hours of wear. 
• Come in 4 shades (Black, Brown, Charcoal, and Eggplant)
• Comes with a decent brush
• Glass packaging with a nice seal
• Easily accessible for repurchasing

Pros:

• Did not crease onto upper lid
• Easily accessible for repurchasing
• Nice packaging
• Affordable
• Comes with a decent brush
• Long wearing

Cons:

• Could not get a think black line right away. I had to go over it a few times to get the color I wanted
• I do not like the consistency of the product, I feel like I need to dig into the product to get enough product to get a thick black line.
• Has a weird smell.
• Doesn't come with a lot of product for the price. 
• Made my eyes itchy on the waterline

Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner:

• There is 5.5g of product (0.19 oz)
• Is $12 at any Inglot counter and online
• Claims to be highly pigmented, provide a rich color after just one application, dries in 60 seconds for a crease proof and smudge proof finish.
• Comes in 2 different lines (Matte and Noble) and the Matte range has 18 different shades. The Noble range has 4.
• Does not come with a brush.
• Plastic packaging, but has a decent seal. 
• Not easily accessible to repurchase unless you live near a counter or are ok with buying online. 

Pros:

• If you wait 60 seconds for this to dry, it will not crease
• Do not need to go over it twice to get a pigmented line
• Easy to grab product out of container
• Creamy
• Waterline safe
• Lots of product for the price. 
• Wide variety of colors to choose from

Cons:

• Plastic packaging
• Very hard to buy, unless you live near a counter
• Can pick up too much product if you don't watch out
• Does crease if you put too much on.

----------------------------------------------------

In all I prefer the Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner in 77 because it is a lot of product for the price, very pigmented, and has a lot of color options.

For me, the Maybelline Eyestudio product itched TERRIBLY, and usually I dont have this problem with eyeliner. I really do like that it came with a brush and had very nice packaging. I do however feel that I'd rather buy just the product and get more of it, compared to getting a brush every time I purchase it. After awhile I would just get a crap load of those brushes. I think it would be great if they included a package that was less expensive in the line that did not have a brush, so us who have purchased it don't need to keep getting the brushes. I also did not get a thick black line, like I wanted, which was unfortunate.

Hope you liked the review 

xoxo Kitten